Subscribe to AfterDawn's weekly newsletter.
Press Release by Knight Vinke Asset Management Concerning GdF-Suez Merger
NEW YORK, September 2 /PRNewswire/ -- Knight Vinke Asset Management (KVAM) applauds the decision of President Nicolas Sarkozy to support the spin-off and public listing of Suez' Environment Division in order to facilitate the negotiation of the merger of Suez and Gaz de France on terms that could suit the shareholders of both companies. The spin-off and public listing of Suez Environment will create one of the largest publicly listed companies in France and a new European champion in the water and waste management area, more focused than its peers and with the potential of playing a leading role in the consolidation of this industry. This solution, which KVAM publicly advocated through a series of 13 full page newspaper advertisements in September and October 2006, will give the Boards and advisers of the two companies increased flexibility to find mutually acceptable merger terms, whilst taking into account the constraints imposed by the State's need to maintain effective control of the resulting entity. Having said this, we wish to make the following three observations: First, we see no benefit to the shareholders of GdF-Suez or to the shareholders of the independently listed Suez Environment in GdF-Suez maintaining a 34% shareholding in Suez Environment. For Suez Environment, the constraint of having a shareholder who wishes to maintain a blocking minority could hamper its development by limiting its ability to raise additional equity capital or use its new listing as a currency for acquisitions. Furthermore, the risk that GdF-Suez' 34% shareholding might some day be sold on the market may harm Suez Environment's stock market performance because of stock overhang. For GdF-Suez, the stake brings absolutely no operational synergies whilst tying up EUR 5 billion in capital that could more wisely be invested in the Group's core energy business. If the issue is ensuring that Suez Environment remains under French control, this can be achieved by other methods which do not uselessly destroy value in this way. Secondly, GdF has very significant unused borrowing capacity and, once the Environment Division has been spun off, could acquire Suez for cash, thereby leaving the French State with a holding of over 70% in GdF-Suez. If necessary, the State's shareholding could be reduced to 50% (or slightly less) once the synergies from combining the two companies (which mainly come from having a more efficient capital structure) start to emerge. This would result in a very significant profit for the French Treasury. Thirdly, Suez' shareholders will be expecting true independence of the financial advisers selected by the Suez Board to provide fairness opinions as to the terms of the proposed merger. This was made clear in a letter sent by almost two dozen major institutional shareholders to the Suez Board (and copied to the Ministry of Finance) late last year. KVAM is an institutional asset management firm which specialises in the linkage between value creation and better governance in large cap public companies. Its clients include some of the world's largest public pension funds and institutional investors, including, in particular, CalPERS - the California Public Employees' Retirement System. Since 2004, as a Suez shareholder, KVAM has played a leading role in promoting public awareness of the value destruction resulting from Suez' inefficient capital structure, its minority holdings in non-core businesses and the fact that it only held 50% in Electrabel, one of its main subsidiaries. On several occasions, KVAM has publicly advocated change in strategy where this would result in value creation for all shareholders. During much of 2006 KVAM actively opposed the terms of the proposed merger between Suez and GdF on the grounds that these were too favourable to GdF, in its opinion. It demonstrated that a solution could more easily be found, taking into account the State's objective of maintaining control of GdF, if Suez' Environment Division were to be spun off and publicly listed.






