IFPI Finland - 'Linux/Mac users should consider buying CD players'

James Delahunty
22 Sep 2005 20:45

So it seems that copyright laws in Finland might make it impossible for consumers to move their music to a MAC or Linux OS but according to Tommi Kyyrä of IFPI Finland, this is fine because listening to music on a computer is simply a "privilege". So what advice would this man or organisation give to users of either Macs or Linux? Consider purchasing a regular CD player.
This was said in a quote from Tommi Kyyrä on tietokone.fi. It was a response given after a question of whether the copyright protection schemes would work on operating systems other than windows was asked. Since it is in Finnish, here's a rough English translation of his reply I got from a blog at tigert.com:

"Now, we need to understand that listening to music on your computer is an extra privilege. Normally people listen to music on their car or through their home stereos", says Kyyrä and continues; "If you are a Linux or Mac user, you should consider purchasing a regular CD player."

And for our Finnish users:
Kysymykseen siitä, toimivatko nämä rajatun kopioinnin tekniikat muissa käyttöjärjestelmissä kuin Windowsisa, Kyyrä ei halua vastata suoraan. "Nyt pitää ymmärtää, että tietokoneella musiikin kuuntelu on extraa. Normaalisti musiikkia kuunnellaan autossa tai stereoiden kautta", Kyyrä sanoo ja jatkaa: "Jos nyt käytät jotain Linuxia tai Macia, kannattaa harkita ihan tavallisen cd-soittimen hankkimista".

Shortly after the original article was published apparently Tietokone magazine received a demand from IFPI Finland to remove it. While the article still exists, the quote has been removed. However there is a screenshot showing the difference between the original and new versions of the article at tigert.com.
I think all would agree that Kyyrä's quote is not very consumer-friendly or generally "fair".
Sources:
Tietokone.fi
Tigert.com
Boing Boing

More from us
We use cookies to improve our service.