|
6 August 2003 11:33 by Lasse "cd-rw.org" Penttinen
| 42 comments
The Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) has launched their new anti-piracy campaign with the slogan copying is stealing. TheRegister takes you back to the pre-digital age, when the movie industry was concerned about the state-of-the-art technology of the time: The VCR. This short article also goes through some of the major and more recent milestones in the battle between free digital content distribution & copyright owners.In another 1980s US case (Sony vs Universal City Studios), the court agreed that video recorders would be used to copy television programmes. UCS claimed that Sony was liable for copyright infringement as it supplied the video recorders. As we can see, the events of recent days, months or years actually aren’t that unique, and that the history is once again repeating itself.
TheRegister
Permalink to this article
| |
Related articles:
Dixons to stop selling VCRs (22 November 2004)
|
|
|
| Discuss this article! |
There are more user comments available, read them here |
| rocky999 (Junior Member) 7 August 2003 8:39 |
|
|
Movie stars can make 10 or 20 million per picture, why, because a-holes will go out to the movies on a Saturday night and spend 8,10 or 12 bucks for a ticket.
They sell some CDs for 16 or 18$,why, because they CAN. Because a-holes will buy them.
Sports stars get millions each year, why, because a-holes will plunk down huge monies for tickets.
We have met the enemy and they are us!
We need to stop buying high priced dvds, cds, movies tickets, etc., and THEN all of the crap will stop!
|
| darthnip (Moderator) 7 August 2003 9:31 |
|
I openly admit to downloading all kinds of stuff, but only for a "test drive". There's no way i'm going to hear 1 song on the radio and run out and plop down $20 for the cd, then the rest of the cd is nothing more than filler crap. so i go download it and if it's worth buying, i DO buy it. downloading it is quick and easy, but nothing compares to having the original with covers and full liner notes etc. My wife wanted to go see tomb raider, so i downloaded it, watched parts of it, then decided it was a good enough movie to go plop down 40 bucks to go to the theater to watch it, so we did. my son wanted to go see the hulk, and after seeing all the sponfed hype on the TV about it, it looked like it would be cool, so i didn't bother with a test drive and we went to see it, my son is 10 and even he said it was one of the worst pieces of crap movies he'd ever seen. thats why i "test drive", the afternoon i saw the hulk in the theaters was the biggest waste of $30 ever. they charge so much so they can cover their advertising and media to promote the movies or music, that they trick you into thinking it's the next best thing since sliced bread, so you go spend your hard earned dollars on it, and it turns out ot be a load of crap, and they call us theives?? what ever happened to "word of mouth" if a movie is truly good, it will make money, same thing with music. they need to not spend as much on advertising, and put that money into making a good complete cd with good songs on it, then maybe the piracy will tone down a bit. but just like any other crime, it will never go away completely.
I wasn't born with enough middle fingers.
http://www.BillLonero.com - check out bill, he rocks and he's way cool.
rod.Liquidirc.com #ad_buddies
|
| DocT (Inactive) 7 August 2003 12:20 |
|
|
The point is that they do it, and people fall for it so they are not gonna stop...they are pretty good at it too i'de say...
|
| Shoey (Inactive) 7 August 2003 13:31 |
|
Things that make you go hhhmmmmmm....
1) Why do companies make tape players with the "record" option?
2) Why do companies make VCR players with a "record" option?
3) Why do companies make cd burners?
4) Why do companies make dvd burners?
I really wanna know why MPAA and RIAA?????
Shoey :)
Certified Computer Technician
http://www.afterdawn.com/general/legal.cfmMobo: MSI KT4VL-6712
CPU: AthlonXP Barton 2500+
Ram: 512 SD-DDR (PC-2700)
nVidia GeForce4 MX440-8x
Maxtor ATA133 80 gig hd
DVD-ROM: LiteOn LTD 165H
CDRW: Memorex52MAXX 2452
|
| Oriphus (AfterDawn Addict) 7 August 2003 17:49 |
|
So that we can...aherm....create our own music...aherm...*cough* and home movies ;-)
|
| nato1200 (Junior Member) 7 August 2003 18:08 |
|
|
oh, HOME movies. ooops. ;)
|
| ABMone (Inactive) 7 August 2003 21:23 |
|
o shut up oriphus nobody's fallin for that. nobody buys a damn burner for home movies nobody is that interesting.
go Nuggets!
|
| QUAKEDS (Junior Member) 8 August 2003 2:42 |
|
|
I openly admit to downloading all kinds of stuff, but only for a "test drive"
MY FRIEND,,, It is the best way to,avoid a big mistake ,,,,, example the hulkkkkkkk.
The actors worked to make the movie and they should get paid...right?
HAVE YOU EVER SEEN AN ACTOR BUYING A DVD MOVIE OR SETTING NEXT TO YOU AT THE MOVIES ??? JAJAJAJA
NOPEEEEEEEEEEEEE
|
| aleb (Newbie) 8 August 2003 5:31 |
|
|
"a living" = millions of $ ???? Good joke.
|
| DocT (Inactive) 8 August 2003 6:12 |
|
|
but all of you know it is true....if you where them you would be doing the exact same thing...you wouldn't give a damn about the struggling people out there all you would care about was the two new mansions that you purchased a week ago.....
|
| aleb (Newbie) 8 August 2003 6:51 |
|
|
Maybe we would be doing the exact same thing, but we are not them and we can choose not to add a few bucks to their millions.. a way or the other.
Anyway, they are "little children" compared to the really rich people, the "1% of USA". :)
|
| DocT (Inactive) 8 August 2003 7:34 |
|
|
nice concept lol...but true
|
| Cirsinn (Junior Member) 8 August 2003 8:12 |
|
|
Well, I for one do download movies..and at first it was just for fun and a challenge to see if I could do the rest. Ok..did that..now what? For me..if I really like the downloaded movie? I support the industry..I load my family up and we see it. Having said that..thank God...I decided to download the Hulk first...what a crappy waste of film.
The movie stars have a certain image to live up to...and it costs big bucks to do that. Why? Because we expect it that's why. I for one will NEVER pay for another DVD movie again..forget it. I mean, what does the movie industry expect me to do. Go out and buy all the DVD's to replace the VHS's I have?? Most times I"m downloading older stuff for the kids....as they already have it on vhs..but since it's becoming more of a trend to have a dvd vs a vhs...I"m gonna continue downloading it. Ok..I"ve supported the industry..I've plunked down my 10bucks to see your movie...now when I download it for home use..don't complain..I"ve done my part.
Sheesh..what do they want? Total control over my life?? Last time I looked I wasn't living under communist rule.
|
| Toiletman (Senior Member) 8 August 2003 18:07 |
|
Seems like I was right. And MPAA, if I like the movie, I would go and see it at the cinema, cuz I want to get the "3xp3ri3nc3" There goes my $10!! And DocT, that is the truest thing I've heard all week.
P.S. Recently I went to see T3..... and it was absolutely, AMAZING!!! GO and see it if you haven't!! You will be missing out a lot if you don't! T3 is amazing!!!
When you are on your deathbed, you will wonder, "Did I waste my life? Was it worth spending all that time on that?" Do not despair, no one has wasted their life. After all, you can only waste something if you throw it away. And you can't throw life away.
|
| trek6500 (Newbie) 9 August 2003 18:54 |
|
|
BobL....Id like to know what you do for a living? Yea, I have to agree that everyone will complain, to some degree, about prices of music cds and movie dvds...But I think that your idea of " just making a living " and mine are a little different. Yes, I have to admit it! Everytime I watch MTV Cribs and read how J. Lo got a 345,000 dollar car for her birthday from her Actor hubby I just tear up. People of the internet!!! Here me now!! I cant take much more of all this copying you are doing!!!! How will they ever survive? Give me a break! How do some of you people even make it to work everyday.
|
| Cirsinn (Junior Member) 10 August 2003 7:03 |
|
|
Well, I can answer that one.....dont' work!! But I'm also disabled..from a car accident that prevents me from working or sitting at this puter too long...I don't download as much as I wish I could...hehehee.
|
| surtur (Inactive) 11 August 2003 0:34 |
|
Here's a thought: Why aren't the companies who make the media going after the companies who make stealing possible? In the U.S., when you aid another in the commission of a crime, it's called "aiding and abetting" or "criminal responsibility for the acts of another." So why isn't Sony music suing Sony computer? Or why isn't Time-Warner suing AOL? Why isn't Vivendi (Universal Studios and Music) shutting down Cegetel?
It should be obvious that they are all owned by the same parent companies. All of this rhetoric by the alphabet gang (MPAA, RIAA, BSA, etc) is just an attempt to generate another revenue stream from an already over-taxed consumer base.
File-sharers aren't sneaky, covert, thieves. It's 60 million people worldwide voting with their wallets. In America alone, when 26 million people do something, it's not a crime, it's a social movement. Hilary Rosen, ex-president of the RIAA, may she rot, admitted once that her job wasn't to stop file-sharing, it was to keep the cash cow alive as long as possible.
I'll stop downloading media when they stop robbing us. And that's all I have to say about that.
"It's the information I want, you can keep the rest."
|
| DocT (Inactive) 11 August 2003 6:14 |
|
|
Robbing you? Can you explain that? becaus im kinda confused because aren't you the one STEALING, yes i said it, "downloading media" is just another term for it.
|
| DocT (Inactive) 11 August 2003 6:16 |
|
|
up untill the last two sentences i thought that was a nice topic you had there
|
| joy53 (Inactive) 11 August 2003 16:36 |
|
|
They always say "whats good for the goose is good for the gander" on another note the RIAA and MPAA have been thieves for years, now they feel they are being robbed. What goes around always come around and payday is a Motherf***er, they can't handle it, you can take that to the bank
|
| mike_eng (Inactive) 11 August 2003 20:17 |
|
|
The RIAA says they're protecting the "writers and musicians" right to a living and to protect their copyrights. What they fail to tell you is that the "writers and musicians" in most cases don't "own" those rights anymore but have been sold, usually to a member company of the RIAA. As an example, if you buy a Beatles album, you are most likely filling Michael Jacksons wallot, not Paul or Ringo's. Or how about Elvis Presley's music? Does Lisa Marie really need more millions?
|
| DocT (Inactive) 12 August 2003 6:35 |
|
|
the point is that it doesn't really matter if they need it...thats business
|
| Ne007 (Junior Member) 12 August 2003 11:25 |
|
|
The MPAA will never EXTORT me again, neither willthe RIAA.
After all that time of them making us think of them as their "Stars"....and making us think we needed to pay them LOADS and LOADS of money.
Well the industry can take their rap, rock and movie stars and shove them up their a@@es for the price they are asking.
THe difference is is that we have leverage and thats what the industry wants to put an end to.
|
| HuSo (Newbie) 13 August 2003 8:03 |
|
|
Dear All, here is how this problem is to us people here in Egypt, just for the sake of argument, to buy a normal DVD from Amazon for instance, it sells for about 15~25 US$, that is about 150 LE(our currency), and the shipping would cost about 10 US$, and customs about another 10 US $, so now the total is about 40 US$, that is 270~300 LE to get a DVD of a movie, why a DVD and not just go to the movies? well, first you do not get all movies here (Matrix II will not show at all here) because of the censorship, and if it does come, it is mostly cut out (because of the censorship also), so I want to watch the full uncut DVD, ok, now an average middle-class Egyptian would make about 1200~1500 LE per month (about 200 US$ ONLY!!!!), so how do you expect to get just one movie with about sixth or fifth of your whole monthly salary !!!!!
I agree that the Actors, Directors...etc have to get well paid for their work, but the pricing for distributing movies should be reasonable, if I make 1000~2000 US$ per month, I'll gladly and easily buy the movie for 20 US$, but I just can't if all I make is about 200 US$, so my only way to watch a goof movie is to download it!!! I consider taking fifth of my salary to watch a movie stealing...don't you think? I will never watch it anyway at that price, so I am not in anyway stealing from the movie-makers, I do not sell or distribute the movie, I just watch something I would have never watched or bought otherwise?
This is how I think of downloading (aka. stealing) vs. Buying the latest movies (only talking about the latest, because eventually I'll find a worn-out cheap & legal VCR version in the local market for any 10yr old movie!)
|
| QUAKEDS (Junior Member) 16 August 2003 2:24 |
|
|
jejeje poor Bob / hey bro I just want to thank you to make this forum the funiest in my opinion of the after..webside,,, bbro,,,you rock with your most epic frase :)
The actors worked to make the movie and they should get paid...right? jajajajajaahh
ps 25 +
|
| bossins (Inactive) 19 August 2003 5:12 |
|
|
cirsinn&joy53=ya both got my vote=As far as
those that seems be a forum plants that attack our positive and free minds to thinkfor ourselves,we are taking care
of bussiness..We are in greaternumbers than
you,BUT it takes PEOPLE like you to MAKE us mad, then we are the SOLDERS..WE have learned how to VOTE, not shoot and this is good.
A hit dog always hollers, those that make out like they are on the side of the actors,are just blowing smoke and are a hussler..Actors do get paid, but they are beat out of a lot of money by thier on kind.
they get very little above the mills they already have gotten. However 95% of us download a few movies(OLD) mostly and old hard to find songs..there is some that do it against ALL laws and they dont care about the ones that KEEP it at home,.however=MPAA & RIAA keepping us alive =I would not have been here if they hadnt..God bless us and keep the faith,IT IS BIGGER THAN YOU!!!!!!!
|
|
|
Latest newsLatest news from AfterDawn.com. Spotify now available on Symbian phones 23 Nov, 2009 Sony confirms 'premium level' for PSN 23 Nov, 2009 | 10 comments Nintendo announces DSi holiday bundles 23 Nov, 2009 iPhone worm can steal banking data 23 Nov, 2009 | 4 comments Roku adds 10 new content channels 23 Nov, 2009 | 5 comments Google Navigation hacked to work outside of US, and on G1 23 Nov, 2009 | 2 comments DSi LL launches in Japan 23 Nov, 2009 | 1 comment China Unicom has bold expectations for iPhone 23 Nov, 2009 | 2 comments Windows 8 coming in 2012? 22 Nov, 2009 | 28 comments Hulu will be dead in two years, says Verizon CEO 22 Nov, 2009 | 7 comments Netflix to stream IFC films 22 Nov, 2009 | 4 comments Wal-Mart selling $78 Blu-ray player on Black Friday, other great deals 22 Nov, 2009 | 6 comments
More news... 
Search for headlinesSearch through our news archive. 
Latest threadsRecently updated discussion threads. More... 
Last week's most popular software downloads
Most popular devicesLast week's most popular products in our product comparison service. More products... 
Top linksMost popular links - Blasteroids.com
Download game trailers, demos and more - TorrentReactor.Net
The most active torrents on the web - Digital-Digest
Latest DivX, XviD, DVD, Blu-Ray, HD DVD News - OpenSubtitles.org
download DivX subtitles from the biggest open database - CDRInfo.com
The Hardware Authority - DVDHelp.us
DVD help, tutorials, FAQ, and very popular free help forum! - dvd ripper
rip DVD to VCD, DivX, MPEG, SVCD, AVI easily and quickly. - Torrentreactor.TO
The most active torrents on the web

|