Mobile/PDA About Us Advertise here


		User name	Password

		Not registered yet? Register here. Lost your password? Click here.

Browse by topic

News

The old Napster case not dismissed

15 July 2004 15:39 by Jari Ketola | 2 comments

Despite numerous attempts by Bertelsmann AG to dismiss the lawsuits filed against it for funding Napster, it will have to, at least, go for a summary judgment. That is because U.S. District Court Judge Marilyn Patel denied Bertelsmann's request to dismiss the case.

Bertelsmann signed a deal with Napster in 2000 and later invested over $80M in the service, which kept the P2P company running up until 2002, when it finally filed for Chapter 11. In early 2003 Bertelsmann was sued by several record labels seeking $17 billion in damages.

The German media giant insists that the funding was intended to keep Napster alive in order to turn it into a legal music service. Judge Patel, however, said that the case has to be answered in court.

"Plaintiffs' allegations that defendants exercised full operational control over Napster during periods in which Napster remained a conduit for infringing activity may be wholly unfounded... Regardless, such questions must be left for resolution upon motions for summary judgment or at trial," Patel wrote.

Bertelsmann will probably repeat its demands for a dismissal when discovery of evidence is complete.

Source: The Register

Permalink to this article

Bertelsmann and UMG announce Napster litigation settlement (6 September 2006)

Napster UK now offering 1 million tracks (26 November 2004)

The ghost of Napster appears in court (21 April 2004)

Bertelsmann seeks dismissal of $17bn lawsuit (14 July 2003)

Universal sues Bertelsmann (13 May 2003)

Bertelsmann acquires Napster (17 May 2002)

Bertelsmann gets ready for the launch of legal Napster (11 July 2001)

Napster makes a deal with BMG (31 October 2000)

« Previous news article
DivX v5.2 released

Next news article »
Apple to launch new iPod next week

Post your comment

Discuss this article!
Toiletman (Senior Member) 16 July 2004 4:34
I have a feeling they should drop the case, and Bertelsmann will get the dismissal he wants. [ + quote]
vans12 (Member) 18 July 2004 14:28
free Bertelsmann!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!free Bertelsmann!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [ + quote]