AfterDawn: Tech news

Google sued by photographers

Written by Andre Yoskowitz @ 08 Apr 2010 12:04 User comments (9)

Google sued by photographers The American Society of Media Photographers, the Graphic Artists Guild, the Picture Archive Council of America, the North American Nature Photography Association, and the Professional Photographers of America have all joined together to sue Google over copyright infringement, claiming that the search giant has scanned millions of books and magazines that include copyrighted images, then displaying those images without consent.
The suit was filed in the same court where Google's long standing Book Search settlement is being considered. In that case, Google agreed to pay a $125 million settlement to compensate the rights holders.

Adds ASMP General Counsel Victor Perlman: "We are seeking justice and fair compensation for visual artists whose work appears in the twelve million books and other publications Google has illegally scanned to date. In doing so, we are giving voice to thousands of disenfranchised creators of visual artworks whose rights we hope to enforce through this class action."



Google responded, via eweek: "We are confident that Google Books is fully compliant with U.S. and international copyright law."

Previous Next  

9 user comments

18.4.2010 00:25
TEC
Unverified new user

AWESOME, Another RETARDED frivolous lawsuit by someone claiming to represent all of these artists. Well if they were really artists they should be happy just being able to show up in Google search. I cant stand stupid lawsuits like this. I am a huge Google fan because they do sooo much for artists and businesses alike. Everyone just seems to be looking for a quick buck these days.

28.4.2010 01:00
pat
Unverified new user

Originally posted by TEC:
AWESOME, Another RETARDED frivolous lawsuit by someone claiming to represent all of these artists. Well if they were really artists they should be happy just being able to show up in Google search. I cant stand stupid lawsuits like this. I am a huge Google fan because they do sooo much for artists and businesses alike. Everyone just seems to be looking for a quick buck these days.
I agree. I have been reading "Angle of Repose" by Stegner and want to see prints by Mary Halleck Foote but cannot because greedy pustules are keeping the biggest library in the universe locked up with lawsuits. Show some compassion. Release the knowledge of the world to the people and be content with your contribution.

38.4.2010 01:51
EvilTwin
Unverified new user

"American Society of Media Photographers, the Graphic Artists Guild, the Picture Archive Council of America, the North American Nature Photography Association, and the Professional Photographers of America" I had to google these names cuz it's the first time i hear about them. Oh, there, I HAD TO GOOGLE that since none of those names meant anything to me. Those guys should be thankful they show up on google. What a bunch of retards...

48.4.2010 02:39

its the Google bots that pull this information off other websites. Google doesn't host any thing save for a cache of every major site

58.4.2010 11:43
Jon OBrien
Unverified new user

I don't get it... aren't photographers paid through the contacted deals they sign with the publishers, whom have already sued Google and have a settlement temporarily in place. Shouldn't they be going to the publisher to collect their royalties or whatever is specified in their contract?

68.4.2010 15:56

Welcome to the modern age were freedom and liberty are sold off to protect copy right, zeig heil!!zeig heil!!

79.4.2010 20:51

This is stupid, really stupid... If the world can't see your arts, what's the point?

89.4.2010 21:31

Originally posted by ZippyDSM:
Welcome to the modern age were freedom and liberty are sold off to protect copy right, zeig heil!!zeig heil!!
Actually, das ist 'sieg heil,' nicht 'zeig heil.'

What's stupid here though, is that it's not like people at Google are in a back room scanning books into a computer. The books are crawled by Google's bots. Also, have you tried to read a full book on Google?! It's practically impossible. Sure you get bits and pieces, but you don't get the full book. It's usually at most a single chapter from the entire book. This just seems like another band of peasants jumping on the possibility of getting some wealth, deserved or not. I can understand if your photo showing up without getting to charge a ticket price, but Google isn't the one to be suing here. The sites that host it and publishers that allow pieces of books to be posted are the ones you guys are after... But they're not the ones with the money.

99.4.2010 21:59

Originally posted by WierdName:
Originally posted by ZippyDSM:
Welcome to the modern age were freedom and liberty are sold off to protect copy right, zeig heil!!zeig heil!!
Actually, das ist 'sieg heil,' nicht 'zeig heil.'

What's stupid here though, is that it's not like people at Google are in a back room scanning books into a computer. The books are crawled by Google's bots. Also, have you tried to read a full book on Google?! It's practically impossible. Sure you get bits and pieces, but you don't get the full book. It's usually at most a single chapter from the entire book. This just seems like another band of peasants jumping on the possibility of getting some wealth, deserved or not. I can understand if your photo showing up without getting to charge a ticket price, but Google isn't the one to be suing here. The sites that host it and publishers that allow pieces of books to be posted are the ones you guys are after... But they're not the ones with the money.

Well copy right owners want to protect every instance of every bit of every copy right they can, and in order to do that public rights and freedoms have to go.

PS:Zippy uses his own spelling and grammar FTW :P

Comments have been disabled for this article.

Latest news

Guide: How to Kick Unwanted Guests from Your Netflix Account Guide: How to Kick Unwanted Guests from Your Netflix Account (26 Jan 2023 2:14)
Sharing a Netflix account with a person in a different location is possible and indeed very common, although the company doesn't necessarily enjoy this behavior from their customers. However, ....
1 user comment
Guide: Turn an Old Computer Into a Chromebook Easily and for Free Guide: Turn an Old Computer Into a Chromebook Easily and for Free (07 Jan 2023 2:11)
Do you know someone whose computer is way beyond its best-before date, and they, unfortunately, do know have the skills or the expertise to do much about it? Or do you own a pile of old laptop ....
3 user comments
How to Choose a Robot Vacuum? How to Choose a Robot Vacuum? (07 Jan 2023 9:12)
Robot vacuums are meant to make day-to-day life easier in several ways. When they are used efficiently, they can keep the house clean continuously - at least when it comes to floors. In addition, ....
4 user comments
Tech year 2022 wrapped up: The rise of the AI, EU to become the much-needed counterweight to tech giants, ... Tech year 2022 wrapped up: The rise of the AI, EU to become the much-needed counterweight to tech giants, ... (01 Jan 2023 2:11)
AfterDawn's wrap-up for the tech year 2022. The rise of the artificial intelligence was probably the most significant change that occurred during the year 2022, but there were many other interesting developments, too.
2 user comments
OPPO to follow Samsung, OnePlus: Promises 4 Android updates, 5 years of patches for upcoming flagships OPPO to follow Samsung, OnePlus: Promises 4 Android updates, 5 years of patches for upcoming flagships (21 Dec 2022 3:45)
OPPO has updated its official Android update policy. Phone manufacturer now promises four major Android operating system updates for its new flagship phones.
4 user comments

News archive