Judge: ISP must reveal subscriber's identity to RIAA

Written by Petteri Pyyny @ 28 Jul 2004 3:13 User comments (7)

In rather surprising decision, a Manhattan -based U.S. federal judge Denny Chin, decided against an earlier ruling by Washington D.C. appeals court. Judge Chin decided that Cablevision, an ISP that operates in New York, New Jersey and Conneticut, has to provide personal details of its subscriber to RIAA even before RIAA has sued the individual for copyright infringements.

The earlier decision in December forced RIAA to sue P2P users as "John Does". It meant that RIAA had to drag the P2P users, who it suspected to violate copyright laws, to court before it could even know their names. Before that decision, RIAA was able to use DMCA legislation to force ISPs to hand out personal details of their subscribers, whether RIAA eventually decided to sue them or not.

However, there were some good aspects in recent ruling as well; court recognized that RIAA (and other copyright holders as well, who opt to use DMCA against individual users) had to have solid case against the user before it could force ISP to hand out the identification details of the user.

Source: ZDNet

<No ESS chips for non-CSS companies >Apple accuses Real of cracking

7 user comments

128.7.2004 21:06

coraggio

Inactive

I know there is still a lot of young people doing some sharing, but are these the people the hated and misguided RIAA really want to taint, harrass and take money from? I wish they would see the forest for the trees. I buy from i-tunes and also use Ripcast 1.9 a great program for ripping off the internet radio and legal and fun. This constant RIAA drone is really getting boring. The percentage of swappers stays the same and they are young innocents, not pros or criminals. Let this phase pass and they will become customers. Houd they and they will become enemies. Congress is in RIAA pocket. Sen Orren Hatch even has some kind of music out, a clear conflict of interest yet he is one of the hashest critics of "scofflaws. I vote the RIAA disband. I also have been buying from some artists directly at artistshare.com One in the fight, coraggio

229.7.2004 06:10

Vular

Send private message to this user

Member

I only download music all the time, I buy what I really like and stuff that only sounds good for about an hour that isn't worth buying I don't. Also the Judge was probably trying to make a name for himself or he was bribed most likely.

329.7.2004 07:23

rfcf2

Send private message to this user

Newbie

I'm curious. www.anonymizer.com claims that if you subscribe to their service your IP address will be hidden. It states that you go through their server first and then they keep changing the IP address when you are going to other websites so the website owner doesn't know what your real IP address is. If that is true, then can RIAA go to Anonymizer and somehow track all of the websites you went to through Anonymizer? I don't know if Anonymizer keeps track of that info. Just a thought.

429.7.2004 18:44

djgizmo

Send private message to this user

Member

Anonymizer is probably over seas and because they're probably hosted by an server thats out of the country, its next to impossible to get them to appear in court etc.

530.7.2004 14:42

JSRife

Inactive

Good point. If someone is from another country other than USA, how in the hell can they get you to appear in court when you live in another country? They say downloading free music on p2p is illegal, how can they bust you for downloading this from the UK? or other countries outside the US? The USA cannot enforce the law in other countries. The problem is technology, you can access anything from anywhere in the World on the internet. You cannot stop technology. Technology has no rules, and technology doesn't listen to written rules on paper. You pay nothing to download files on P2P, on the other hand the user you are getting the file from is making no money off the file either. The music isn't being sold, it's just given away for nothing, and that hurts sells for the record company because you won't buy an album you already got for free right? Oh well, no money is being made on the deal, it's just money the record company assumes they lost, they shouldn't assume anything.

630.7.2004 19:18

zombieman

Send private message to this user

Member

the usa enforces law all over the world. What do you think the past 3 wars in a irag have been over. technically.

72.8.2004 08:41

Rodgers

Inactive

Another example of an activist Judge going off the deep end. I wonder if he was paid off by the RIAA? Best to all! Rodgers

Comments have been disabled for this article.

	Netflix buys HBO and Warner Bros studios (05 Dec 2025 8:04) Netflix has won the bidding competition for media giant Warner Bros and will acquire HBO as well as the Warner Bros film studios.
	Massive Android 0-day vulnerability found - here's what you should do immediately (08 Nov 2025 5:35) A very serious security flaw has been found in the Android operating system, allowing malicious code to be executed on a phone or tablet.
	Review: Roborock Saros Z70 - robot vacuum with an arm (20 Oct 2025 6:13) In out in-depth review of Roborock Saros Z70 we put the robot vacuum through a 3 month test period, where we observed its work in normal home. The sci-fi -like arm of Z70 was a little bit disappointing, due its limited functionality.
	End of an era: TiVo stops making DVRs (14 Oct 2025 4:12) TiVo, once synonumous with digital TV recording in the United States and in select other countries, has stopped making DVR devices as of October, 2025.
	Strava takes Garmin to court (02 Oct 2025 2:30) The world's perhaps best-known sports app developer Strava has filed a lawsuit against American sports watch manufacturer Garmin, accusing the company of patent infringement. 1 user comment

	Guide: Phone battery drains quickly - how to fix (iPhone / Android) In this guide, we go through the most typical reasons for rapid battery drain with phones, and look at potential reasons or solutions.
	Does your phone rattle? Here's why it happens When you shake your phone and hear a light rattle, clatter, or jingle, it's likely not broken. The culprit is probably the optical image stabilization (OIS) system in your phone's camera, meaning everything is functioning as it should. 2 user comments
	GUIDE: Wi-Fi speeds are slow? Here are some tips Having problems with Wi-Fi speed and stability at home? Here are some tips to follow to alleviate the issues. 1 user comment
	Guide: Is Your Wi-Fi Sluggish or Slow? Here's How to Fix Do you have problems with you Wi-Fi? Slow connection or is it cutting off constantly? This guide aims to remedy these problems. 1 user comment
	What happens if you don't update Android? Sometimes it can be tempting to avoid updating to a new Android version. What happens if you decide to delay major updates to the OS?

Judge: ISP must reveal subscriber's identity to RIAA

7 user comments

Latest news

Reviews

Guides

News archive

Subscribe

Sections:

Follow us:

	Review: Roborock Saros Z70 - robot vacuum with an arm In out in-depth review of Roborock Saros Z70 we put the robot vacuum through a 3 month test period, where we observed its work in normal home. The sci-fi -like arm of Z70 was a little bit disappointing, due its limited functionality.
	Roborock Saros 10 review - Great, but not perfect We tested Roborock Saros 10 robot vacuum for more than two months in order to see whether it is really worth its hefty price tag. The mopping, self-emptying Saros 10 was mostly great, even perfect. But its object avoidance was bit disappointing. 1 user comment
	Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra review - obstacle avoidance doesn't work as it should, otherwise almost perfect robot vacuum We put the Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra through a very, very long review process. The $1800 mopping robot vacuum is almost perfect, but its obstacle avoidance was surprisingly bad, considering the price - and compared to its competitors.