AfterDawn: Tech news

RIAA appeals Thomas-Rasset case

Written by Andre Yoskowitz @ 23 Aug 2011 1:52 User comments (5)

RIAA appeals Thomas-Rasset case As expected, the RIAA has appealed the latest Jammie Thomas-Rasset decision.
Citing the court's failure to classify Thomas-Rasset's actions as a "distribution" under 106(3) of the Copyright Act, the RIAA believes the defendant will likely repeat her previous actions and violate the Copyright Act.

If the jury can define "distribution" as the RIAA wants it, it will likely result in a third trial.

Here is the backstory:

In 2006, Jammie Thomas-Rasset was sent a letter asking her to settle (for $3300) over alleged unauthorized file sharing of 24 tracks.

She refused and decided to take the case to court.

In 2007, Thomas-Rasset was found liable for $1.92 million in damages, but a retrial saw the fine dropped to $220,000. In 2010, however, a judge reduced the award to $54,000. The RIAA told Thomas-Rasset that they would accept $25,000, if she would agree to ask the judge to remove the decision from the record. She did not accept the terms of the deal and the trial went to part 3. Later that year, Thomas lost again in court, with a jury finding her liable for $1.5 million in copyright infringement damages. The Minnesota woman appealed.



in July, the judge reduced the verdict to $54,000 again, calling the original jury award "appalling."

The RIAA has now prolonged the longest saga ever involving pirated music tracks.

Previous Next  

5 user comments

123.8.2011 04:01

I would think the next court will be asking RIAA why they have appealed and to prove why she should be paying more for the songs.

223.8.2011 04:56
ps3lvanub
Inactive

You go girl!




IMPORTANT: If you hate Sony for being so corrupt, copy this image into your signature too!

323.8.2011 07:24

Quote:

Citing the court's failure to classify Thomas-Rasset's actions as a "distribution" under 106(3) of the Copyright Act, the RIAA believes the defendant will likely repeat her previous actions and violate the Copyright Act.

Yeah...because the fine is only about 2.5 years wages for her; I'm sure she will just shrug it off and go back to doing what she was doing.

Actually, come to think of it, she will probably be pirating music again regardless; she can never pay for it again.

423.8.2011 11:15

Reading the back story anyone would think the RIAA managed to pick their own or influence the judge when they appeal.

How much more than the $54,000 have they spend on lawyers already on this...?

523.8.2011 12:13

I would imagine this appeal going no where at this point. Like how many times has this case been appealed? Sooner or later the judge is just going to ream on the RIAA for wasting tax payers $.

Comments have been disabled for this article.

Latest news

Guide: How to Kick Unwanted Guests from Your Netflix Account Guide: How to Kick Unwanted Guests from Your Netflix Account (26 Jan 2023 2:14)
Sharing a Netflix account with a person in a different location is possible and indeed very common, although the company doesn't necessarily enjoy this behavior from their customers. However, ....
1 user comment
Guide: Turn an Old Computer Into a Chromebook Easily and for Free Guide: Turn an Old Computer Into a Chromebook Easily and for Free (07 Jan 2023 2:11)
Do you know someone whose computer is way beyond its best-before date, and they, unfortunately, do know have the skills or the expertise to do much about it? Or do you own a pile of old laptop ....
3 user comments
How to Choose a Robot Vacuum? How to Choose a Robot Vacuum? (07 Jan 2023 9:12)
Robot vacuums are meant to make day-to-day life easier in several ways. When they are used efficiently, they can keep the house clean continuously - at least when it comes to floors. In addition, ....
4 user comments
Tech year 2022 wrapped up: The rise of the AI, EU to become the much-needed counterweight to tech giants, ... Tech year 2022 wrapped up: The rise of the AI, EU to become the much-needed counterweight to tech giants, ... (01 Jan 2023 2:11)
AfterDawn's wrap-up for the tech year 2022. The rise of the artificial intelligence was probably the most significant change that occurred during the year 2022, but there were many other interesting developments, too.
2 user comments
OPPO to follow Samsung, OnePlus: Promises 4 Android updates, 5 years of patches for upcoming flagships OPPO to follow Samsung, OnePlus: Promises 4 Android updates, 5 years of patches for upcoming flagships (21 Dec 2022 3:45)
OPPO has updated its official Android update policy. Phone manufacturer now promises four major Android operating system updates for its new flagship phones.
4 user comments

News archive