AfterDawn: Tech news

Apple's HomePod and Siri left on last place in a smart speaker bout

Written by Matti Robinson @ 13 Feb 2018 2:06 User comments (1)

Apple's HomePod and Siri left on last place in a smart speaker bout

Apple finally managed to release their smart speaker to the public last week. First shown to the public last summer, Apple HomePod, was supposed to be launched by Holiday season where it would wreck havoc, or that's what Apple hoped for at least.
Now that the device has landed on many reviewer's desks, it has been torn apart, although for now only figurative as we wait for JerryRigEverything or iFixit to grab one. A company by the name of Loup Ventures, that calls itself "a research-driven venture capital firm", has compared the new speaker and its assistant to the competition.

HomePod has been receiving quite a bit of criticism from reviewers for not having any connections or supporting Bluetooth. It also is not meant only for the most extreme Apple enthusiast, since it doesn't support Android phones or even really Apple Music competitors like the twice as popular Spotify.

However, most are very impressed with the sound quality that might not be as loud or as bass-y as on Google Home Max, but offers a really balanced good audio experience.



When it comes to comparing Siri, Loup's test seems to be the best so far. A fairly scientific test included a total of 782 inquiries on four of the most popular assistants on four different smart speakers. They had the Amazon's Echo with Alexa, Google Home with Google Assistant, Apple's HomePod with Siri, as well as a Harman Kardon Invoke with Microsoft's Cortana.

The test revealed that Apple has still a long way to go with Siri. Google managed to take the crown with a success rate of 81% with Amazon taking the second spot with 64%. Even the Harman Kardon speaker topped Apple, and HomePod was left last with just over half questions answered correctly.

The testers, however, noted that even though Siri only managed to answer 52.3% of the questions appropriately Siri did hear and understand the question nearly every single time. This means that Apple's listening prowess is way better than its answering abilities at this point.

They also reminded that Apple has just released their device while Amazon has been in business for a long time. HomePod doesn't currently support for example navigation-related questions which took it down quite a bit.

All in all Loup Ventures was impressed with Apple's effort this early on in HomePod's life cycle.

Previous Next  

1 user comment

122.2.2018 10:16

It just shows that Siri is really dumb compared to others. Siri has been on other devices for a while now so why does it not have proper / correct response? If its deciphering of the question is accurate then why should anyone other than "absolute applefans" shell out ridiculously high price for it?

I guess the buyer too would be at the same "smarts" - read "really dumb " - level as the speakers!!!

Comments have been disabled for this article.

Latest news

Roomba Combo j7+ review - Clever trick allows robot vacuum finally to tackle home with rugs and carpets Roomba Combo j7+ review - Clever trick allows robot vacuum finally to tackle home with rugs and carpets (06 Jun 2023 9:19)
Roomba Combo j7+ is the very first Roomba model to combine robot vacuum with mopping features. And Roomba Combo j7+ does all that with a very clever trick, which tackles the problem with mopping and carpets. But is it any good? We found out.
Neato, the robot vacuum company, ends its operations Neato, the robot vacuum company, ends its operations (02 May 2023 3:38)
Neato Robotics has ceased its operations. American robot vacuum pioneer founded in 2005 has finally called it quits and company will cease its operations and sales. Only a skeleton crew will remain who will keep the servers running until 2028.
4 user comments
How to Send Messages to Yourself on WhatsApp How to Send Messages to Yourself on WhatsApp (20 Mar 2023 1:25)
The world's most popular messaging platform, Meta-owned WhatsApp has enabled sending messages to yourself. While at first, this might seem like an odd feature, it can be very useful in a lot of situations. ....
18 user comments
How to Enable Bluetooth on Stadia Controller How to Enable Bluetooth on Stadia Controller (11 Feb 2023 1:04)
Google shut down its streaming game service Stadia late last month and this means that some people have Stadia controllers lying around that seem to be of no use. That is fortunately not the ....
2 user comments
Guide: How to Kick Unwanted Guests from Your Netflix Account Guide: How to Kick Unwanted Guests from Your Netflix Account (26 Jan 2023 2:14)
Sharing a Netflix account with a person in a different location is possible and indeed very common, although the company doesn't necessarily enjoy this behavior from their customers. However, ....

News archive